Probationary Evaluations in Workday

This document provides an overview of the Workday tasks and responsibilities related to probationary evaluations.

New Employee Goals and Expectations (Formerly 30-Day Conversation)

Launching the Evaluation (HR)

On the employee's start date HR receives task titled Goal Setting Initiation. Within the task select the Start Performance Review button.

Screen shot of Goal Setting Initiation task in Workday.

In the Start Performance Review window, enter the following:

    • Employee Name
    • Template (New Employee Goals and Expectations)
    • Dates (start and end date are both the employee’s hire or transfer date)

Click Submit.

This will launch a task with the manager to begin filling in the goals and expectations evaluation.

Screen shot of Start Performance Review window in Workday.

Manager Evaluation

  1. Once launched by HR, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Manager Evaluation: Goals & Expectations. The manager clicks the Get Started button.

Screen shot of Manager Evaluation: Goals & Expectations Task in Workday.

2. In the Responsibilities and Expectations window, the employees job responsibilities will pull through from the Standard Job Description (SJD).

Manager should:

    •  add any unique responsibilities that are part of the employee's job.
    • delete any responsibilities that do not apply to the employee's job.
    • enter expectations related to each specific responsibility in the comment fields. 

Managers should NOT:

    •  edit job responsibilities from what pulls from the SJD.

Screen shot of responsibilities window of perfomance evaluation in Workday.

3. In the Goals window, the manager will add teh initial goals for the new employee.

    • The initial Goals and Expectations Evaluation is the time to set the first goals for the employee. No existing goals will be present in this evaluation. 
    • Each goal should be given a clear description and include a due date. Due dates should align with the end dates of future evaluation periods.
    • Goals should always be given a status of Not Started when they are added to the employees evaluation.

Screen shot of the Goals window within a performance evaluation in Workday.

4. The Complete Manager Evaluation window is the opportunity for the manager to review and edit what they have entered in the evaluation. There is also an option to Save for Later that allows managers to save their work if they are not ready to submit the evaluation. Once completed, the manager must click the Submit button. 

Screen shot of Complete Manager Evaluation window in Workday.

5. After clicking the Submit button, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Schedule Review Discussion. Outside of Workday the manager should work with the employee to schedule a date and time to discuss the evaluation.

Clicking Submit on this task will launch the employee review task in Workday. 

    • If the manager would like to give the employee an opportunity to view the evaluation before their meeting, the manager should click Submit on this task once the meeting has been scheduled. 
    • If the manager does not want the employee to view the evaluation in advance, the manager should wait to submit this task until after the meeting with the employee. 

Screen shot of Schedule Review Discussion in Workday.

Employee Review of Evaluation Content

  1. Once the evaluation is submitted by the manager, the employee will receive a task in Workday titled Provide Employee Review Comments. The employee clicks the Get Started button.
Screen shot of Employee Review task in Workday.
2. The employee reviews the content of the evaluation and selects a status from the status drop down. At this point, the employee has the opportunity to enter comments. The employee must click the Submit button on the task. 

Screen shot of Employee Review task in Workday.

Manager Review of Comments

  1. Once the employee has submitted their status and comments, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Provide Manager Review Comments. The manager clicks the Get Started button.

Screen shot of Provide Manager Review task in Workday.

2. Manager reviews the status and comments submitted by the employee, adds their own status and comments, and clicks the Submit button to finalize the evaluation. Once finalized a "Successfully Completed" box will pop up letting the manager know this evaluation is finalized. 

Screen shot of manager review task in Workday.

Probation Midpoint Evaluation (Formerly Mid-Probation Conversation)

Diagram of Probation Midpoint Evaluation business process

Launch Probation Midpoint Evaluation (HR)

HR does not receive a task to initiate this evaluation. HR Assistants will be keeping track of due dates for these evaluations outside of Workday.

Screen Shot of Start Perfomance Review window in Workday

Manager Sets Evaluation Content

  1. Once launched by HR, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Set Content:Probation Midpoint Evaluation. The manager clicks the Get Started button.

Screen shot of Manager Evaluation: Goals & Expectations Task in Workday.

2. In the Responsibilities and Expectations window, the employees job responsibilities and expectations will pull through from the Goals & Expectations Evaluation.

Manager should:

    • add any additional unique responsibilities that are part of the employee's job.
    • delete any responsibilities that no longer apply to the employee's job.
    • update expectations related to each specific responsibility in the comment fields if necessary. 

Managers should NOT:

    •  edit job responsibilities from what is pulled from the SJD.

Once complete, the manager click's the submit button to launch the employee's self-evaluation.

Screen shot of responsibilities window of perfomance evaluation in Workday.

Employee Self Evaluation

  1. Once launched by the manager, the employee will receive a task in Workday titled Complete Self Evaluation. The employee clicks the Get Started button.

Screen shot of employee self evaluation task in Workday.

2. The employee rates each job responsibility by selecting a rating from the drop down. The employee also has the option to enter comments if the wish to elaborate on the rating they assigned. Click the Next button to page through all the job responsibilities.

See this Performance Ratings in Workday resource for help defining the rating options. 

Once the employee has rated all the job responsibilities they save and submit to launch the manager evaluation. 

screen shot of employee rating of job responsibilities in Workday.

Complete Manager Evaluation

  1. The manager will receive a Workday task titled Manager Evaluation: Midpoint Evaluation. The manager clicks the Get Started button. 

Screen shot of Manager Evaluation task in Workday.

2. Within the Evaluate Responsibilities window the manager enters ratings for each job responsibility and has the option to enter explanations in the comments fields. In this window, managers are also able to see the ratings and comments entered during the employee self-evaluation. 

See this Performance Ratings in Workday resource for help defining the rating options.

Screen shot of manager rating window in Workday.

Screen shot of ratings window in Workday

3. In the Goals window, the manager can either add new goals or update existing goals. 

    • The initial goals will pull through from the Goals and Expectations Evaluation. 
    • Descriptions, due dates, and statuses should be updated to reflect the progress made during the period being evaluated.
    • New goals can be added if applicable.
    • Goals should always be given a status of Not Started when they are added to the employees evaluation.
    • Goal due dates should align with future evaluation period end dates. 

Screen shot of Goals window in Workday.

4. There is the option to upload supporting documents to the evaluation if applicable. These documents will become part of the employee's personnel file. 

5. Once all ratings, expecations, and goals have been entered the manager provides an overall rating for the evaluation. Again there is the option to enter an explanation in the comments fields. 

After the overall rating is entered the manager has the option to review the evaluation and either Save for Later or Submit. 

6. After clicking the Submit button, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Schedule Review Discussion. Outside of Workday the manager should work with the employee to schedule a date and time to discuss the evaluation.

Clicking Submit on this task will launch the employee review task in Workday. 

    • If the manager would like to give the employee an opportunity to view the evaluation before their meeting, the manager should click Submit on this task once the meeting has been scheduled. 
    • If the manager does not want the employee to view the evaluation in advance, the manager should wait to submit this task until after the meeting with the employee. 


Employee Review of Evaluation Content

  1. Once the evaluation is submitted by the manager, the employee will receive a task in Workday titled Provide Employee Review Comments. The employee clicks the Get Started button.
2. The employee reviews the content of the evaluation and selects a status from the status drop down. At this point, the employee has the opportunity to enter comments. The employee must click the Submit button on the task. 

Screen shot of Employee Review task in Workday.

Manager Review of Comments

  1. Once the employee has submitted their status and comments, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Provide Manager Review Comments. The manager clicks the Get Started button.

Screen shot of Provide Manager Review task in Workday.

2. Manager reviews the status and comments submitted by the employee, adds their own status and comments, and clicks the Submit button to finalize the evaluation. Once finalized a "Successfully Completed" box will pop up letting the manager know this evaluation is finalized. 

Screen shot of manager review task in Workday.

Probation Final Evaluation (Formerly Summary Probation Evaluation)

A diagram of a performance reviewAI-generated content may be incorrect.

Launch Probation Final Evaluation (HR)

Forty-Five days prior to the probation period end date HR receives a task to start the performance review titled Probation Period Final Evaluation Reminder: Review Probation Period. Completing this task will launch the Probation Final Evaluation task for the manager.  Screen shot of Probation Final task in Workday

Manager Sets Evaluation Content

  1. Once launched by HR, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Set Content:Probation Midpoint Evaluation. The manager clicks the Get Started button.

Screen shot of Manager Evaluation: Goals & Expectations Task in Workday.

2. In the Responsibilities and Expectations window, the employees job responsibilities and expectations will pull through from the Probation Midpoint Evaluation.

Manager should:

    • add any additional unique responsibilities that are part of the employee's job.
    • delete any responsibilities that no longer apply to the employee's job.
    • update expectations related to each specific responsibility in the comment fields if necessary. 

Managers should NOT:

    •  edit job responsibilities from what is pulled from the SJD.

Once complete, the manager click's the submit button to launch the employee's self-evaluation.

Screen shot of responsibilities window of perfomance evaluation in Workday.

3. The Probation Final evaluation includes three discussion question regarding Job Engagement that the employee and manager will be required to answer during the following evaluation steps. These questions can be viewed by the manager at this time. 

screen shot of job engagement questions

Employee Self Evaluation

  1. Once launched by the manager, the employee will receive a task in Workday titled Complete Self Evaluation. The employee clicks the Get Started button.

screen shot of employee self evaluation task

2. The employee rates each job responsibility by selecting a rating from the drop down. The employee also has the option to enter comments if the wish to elaborate on the rating they assigned. Click the Next button to page through all the job responsibilities.

See this Performance Ratings in Workday resource for help defining the rating options.

Once the employee has rated all the job responsibilities they save and submit to launch the manager evaluation. 

screen shot of employee ratings in Workday

3. Employee answers the Job Engagement questions.

Screen shot of job engagement questions in Workday.

Complete Manager Evaluation

  1. The manager will receive a Workday task titled Manager Evaluation: Probation Final Evaluation. The manager clicks the Get Started button. 

Screen shot of Manager Evaluation task in Workday.

2. Within the Evaluate Responsibilities window, the manager enters ratings for each job responsibility and has the option to enter explanations in the comments fields.

See this Performance Ratings in Workday resource for help defining the rating options.

Rating explanations in the comment field will pull forward from the previous evaluation. Managers should update the rating explanation accordingly for the current review period. 

In this window, managers are also able to see the ratings and comments entered during the employee self-evaluation. 

Screen shot of manager rating window in Workday.

Screen shot of ratings window in Workday

3. Manager answers the Job Engagement questions.

4. In the Goals window, the manager can either add new goals or update existing goals. 

    • The goals will pull through from the Probation Midpoint Evaluation. 
    • Descriptions, due dates, and statuses should be updated to reflect the progress made during the period being evaluated.
    • New goals can be added if applicable.
    • Goals should always be given a status of Not Started when they are added to the employees evaluation.
    • Goal due dates should align with future evaluation period end dates. 

Screen shot of Goals window in Workday.

4. There is the option to upload supporting documents to the evaluation if applicable. These documents will become part of the employee's personnel file. 

5. Once all ratings, expecations, and goals have been entered the manager provides an overall rating for the evaluation. Again there is the option to enter an explanation in the comments fields. 

After the overall rating is entered the manager has the option to review the evaluation and either Save for Later or Submit. 

6. After clicking the Submit button, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Schedule Review Discussion. Outside of Workday the manager should work with the employee to schedule a date and time to discuss the evaluation.

Clicking Submit on this task will launch the employee review task in Workday. 

    • If the manager would like to give the employee an opportunity to view the evaluation before their meeting, the manager should click Submit on this task once the meeting has been scheduled. 
    • If the manager does not want the employee to view the evaluation in advance, the manager should wait to submit this task until after the meeting with the employee. 


Employee Review of Evaluation Content

  1. Once the evaluation is submitted by the manager, the employee will receive a task in Workday titled Provide Employee Review Comments. The employee clicks the Get Started button.
2. The employee reviews the content of the evaluation and selects a status from the status drop down. At this point, the employee has the opportunity to enter comments. The employee must click the Submit button on the task. 

Screen shot of Employee Review task in Workday.

Manager Review of Comments

  1. Once the employee has submitted their status and comments, the manager will receive a task in Workday titled Provide Manager Review Comments. The manager clicks the Get Started button.

Screen shot of Provide Manager Review task in Workday.

2. Manager reviews the status and comments submitted by the employee, adds their own status and comments, and clicks the Submit button to finalize the evaluation. Once finalized a "Successfully Completed" box will pop up letting the manager know this evaluation is finalized. 

Screen shot of manager review task in Workday.

    Probation Period Review

    Thirty days prior to the probation end date the manager receives a Review Probation Period task. The manager must indicate the Probation Outcome and Action. See the Review Probation Period KB for details regarding the Probation Outcomes and resulting workflows. Managers are encouraged to work with their HR Business Partner in instances of performance concerns and/or when probation outcomes are anything other than "Successfully Completed". 

    Once the manager completes the task, HR receives a task notifying them of the outcome.

    NOTE: This Probation Review is required for Instructional Academic Staff Faculty. This WILL NOT launch the evaluation with the manager. 

     Workers with Multiple Positions

    Request Performance Feedback


    Request Performance Feedback (HRA)

    Performance evaluations are tied to an employee’s primary position. If the employee has additional jobs, the Talent Partner (Supervisory) will receive a task to Request Performance Feedback. The HRA must add the name of the non-primary job's manager and submit the task. This will route a task to supervisor of the non-primary job to add their comments to the performance file. 

    Feedback will be automatically added to the Performance tab on the worker profile.

      A diagram of a customer feedbackAI-generated content may be incorrect.

      Resources

      Performance Review Setup at Workday Go-Live

      Review Probation Period

      Responding to a Give Feedback Request - Managers

      Performance Reviews Overview

      Performance Ratings in Workday



      Keywords:
      30 day, mid-probation, probation, goals, expectations, summary, performance, review, non-primary 
      Doc ID:
      151912
      Owned by:
      Sarah J. in SMPH Human Resources
      Created:
      2025-06-23
      Updated:
      2025-08-13
      Sites:
      SMPH Human Resources