Buying Guide - Video Streaming Devices

DoIT Tech Store @ UW-Madison

Tech Store @ UW-Madison
See our YouTube channel Find us on Facebook Follow us on TwitterBuyer's GuideCustomer ServiceCart Cart image

This document is intended to help you pick the perfect streaming device based on your needs.

Buying Guide - Video Streaming Devices

Roku 2
Advantages:
Huge variety of streaming apps - When it comes to app selection, nobody beats Roku as they have over 1,000 apps (called channels).  They're often the first to get new channels and the company is known for updating boxes for a long time after they're released.
Fast chip - The knock on previous generations of Roku was the relatively weak chip powering it which could make some apps feel sluggish.  The Roku 2 is as fast as the Roku 3 and is much improved and feels very responsive.
Cross-platform search - Roku can search for a movie, TV show, actor or director on any supported video service (currently Netflix, Hulu Plus, Amazon Instant, HBO Go, Vudu, Crackle, M-Go and Blockbuster On Demand).  This makes it easy to find the title you wanted to watch on the most affordable or convenient service available.
Small size - The Roku is only 3.5 x 3.5 x 1 inches, which is about the same as the Apple TV  It does require a power cable with a larger plug.
Price - At $70, it is fairly inexpensive for a full-featured streaming box.


Disadvantages:
Not easiest to push content from phone/tablet to TV via Roku - You can push photos and personal video to your TV from your phone or tablet via the Roku app but you can't push all apps to your TV through it.
Personal media requires Plex - If you have a video file on your computer you want to play on your TV, you need the Plex channel and software on your computer.  It's powerful but another piece of software.
4K requires Roku 4 - If you need 4K content you should upgrade to the Roku 4 at a premium.
Headphone jack in the remote - The Roku 3 has a unique headphone jack in the remote that will redirect audio from the TV to any headphones plugged in.  There are also separate volume controls on the remote which are independent of the TV volume. This feature isn't available on the Roku 2.
Motion control remote - The Roku 3 remote has motion-sensing capabilities which allows you to play games including Angry Birds.

Recommended for:
The Roku is perfect for people who use a wide variety of streaming services and want the easiest way to access them.  The remote with headphones is also ideal for those who want to watch TV without disturbing others.  There are also other models if you want to pay less and don't need all the features of the flagship model.

Apple TV
Advantages:
Works great with Apple ecosystem, especially iTunes - If you purchase most of your content through iTunes, AppleTV is going to be the easiest way to get that content on your TV.  If you subscribe to iTunes Match, you can also get your cloud music library to play as well.  You can also access iTunes Radio.
AirPlay is easiest way to get your iOS app to the TV - Nothing beats the AppleTV for ease of use in getting your iPhone/iPod/iPad screen to the TV.  Screen mirroring also works very well if you have a newer Mac.
App library is growing - Apple had previously been lacking in app selection but it has improved greatly over the last year.
Small size - At 3.9 x 3.9 x 0.9 inches, the AppleTV is roughly the same size as the Roku 3.  It does require an external power cable.

Disadvantages:
Fewer apps than Roku - While the app selection has improved, it is still a significantly smaller library than the Roku's library.
iTunes centric - If you're not purchasing your music and video through iTunes, you'll have trouble getting your content to the screen, particularly if you use Amazon or Vudu - they don't have an AppleTV app.
Remote is very basic - The remote is simple and easy to use but lacks the versatility and features of the Roku remote.

Recommended for:
If you're an Apple and iTunes user, this is the perfect streaming box for you.  If you purchase your content through other sources, you might want to look at a different option.

Chromecast
Advantages:
Cheap price - At $35, the Chromecast is the cheapest option of the three presented here.
Very small size - The Chromecast is about the size of a USB flash drive.  It does need power from a USB port on your TV or from an external power adapter.
Covers major apps - The Chromecast covers most of the major apps like Netflix and YouTube

Disadvantages:
Extremely small app library - While the major streaming apps are covered, it doesn't have the thousands of options that the Roku has covered.
No cross-platform search - The Chromecast has no way to search through multiple video services for a specific title.
No on-screen UI or remote - Since the Chromecast doesn't ship with a remote, you use your smartphone or tablet as the input device.
Screen mirroring doesn't work well - While this feature will likely be improved in the future, it is currently in beta and has some bugs.  You can use to to project any content from a Chrome tab to your TV.

Recommended for:
The price makes the Chromecast ideal for people who want to get the major streaming services to their TV at the lowest possible cost.

Amazon Fire TV Stick
Advantages:
Voice search - A built-in microphone on the remote allows for voice search.
Parental Controls - Easily limit the amount of time and content than children can access.
Small hardware size - Competes directly with the Roku Streaming Stick
Price - At $39, very cheap option to get your media onto a screen.

Disadvantages:
Relatively expensive - At $99, it is on the high end of cost for streaming players.  It costs additional money if you want the game controller to play games.
Personal media requires Plex - If you have a video file on your computer you want to play on your TV, you need the Plex channel and software on your computer.  It's powerful but another piece of software.
Apps - While the app selection is better than the AppleTV and Chromecast, it is significantly smaller than the selection on the Roku
Speed - The Fire TV Stick is slower than a Roku 2/3 and may see occasional lag when selecting items.

Recommended for:
There are three major groups that this would appeal to - Android gamers who want to game on a TV, people who are heavily invested in the Amazon ecosystem and/or own a Kindle Fire, and parents with children that they want to have access to the Fire TV but limit their time.

Note: The DoIT Tech Store is unable to stock the Chromecast as Google has an exclusive reseller agreement with several major outlets.  The Apple TV, Amazon Fire Stick and entire Roku line are stocked by the Tech Store.



Keywords:roku roku3 appletv chromecast apple tv   Doc ID:37752
Owner:Nick R.Group:DoIT Tech Store
Created:2014-02-19 10:12 CDTUpdated:2016-08-02 12:12 CDT
Sites:DoIT Help Desk, DoIT Tech Store
Feedback:  1   1