L&S Best Practices for Chair/Director Selection Process
This document supplements Faculty Policies and Procedures around Departmental Chair Selection (see FPP 5.30) with additional specificity from the College of Letters & Science to ensure equity and transparency. Note: Throughout this document, the term “chair” refers to department chairs, school directors, and program directors.
- Term of Office
- Term Length – The term of office for a chair is one year, and chair selection occurs annually. There is no limit to the number of terms that may be served.
- Service Expectations – Chairs are expected to serve for a minimum of three years, with a preference for five years.
- Eligibility
-
- Chair Eligibility – All members of the Department’s Executive Committee (See FPP 5.20) are eligible to be chair.
- Voting Eligibility – All tenured, tenure-track faculty, and affiliate faculty with joint governance appointments are eligible to vote for chair. If a unit wishes to invite academic staff and university staff to participate in voting, the Executive Committee must vote to approve of this at the start of each academic year.
-
- Elections Process
- Incumbent Chair – If the current chair is within their three-to-five year term, only a confidence vote is required. Voting should be conducted using a Qualtrics survey by early February at the latest, and the results reported by the Department Administrator to the Dean’s Office by March 15. If the current chair declines to continue their term or the confidence vote fails, a full election is initiated.
- Nomination Period – A full election begins with a nomination period, during which all voting members are invited to submit nominations or self-nominations for chair to the Department Administrator. Nominees will be contacted to confirm their willingness to serve. If no candidate emerges from this process, contact your Associate Dean for guidance.
- Balloting – All nominated and willing candidates will be listed on the ballot. If there is more than one candidate, the ballot will also include brief statements from each candidate outlining their goals as chair. Voting is conducted using a Qualtrics survey.
- Results – All vote totals are reported by the Department Administrator to the Dean’s Office by March 15. The Dean will make the final appointment decision. Units may conduct their election at any point during the academic year.
Setting Up Your Ballot in Qualtrics
- Create the Survey – Log into Qualtrics through https://uwmadison.qualtrics.com/ and click “Create a new project.” Select “Survey” and choose “Create a blank survey project.” Name the survey with your department/school name and the year for the election. Example name: Department of Jurassic Studies Chair Election for 2027-28.
- Build Your Ballot – Add a Multiple Choice question where the choices include the name of the candidate(s):
Please select your preferred candidate for [Chair/Director].
-
-
- Candidate A
- Candidate B
-
- Give the Dean’s Office Access to Results – In the Survey, go to Tools (button is above the survey questions) > Collaborate. Under “Add the people you want to collaborate with” type Ali Burke (acburke2@wisc.edu) and click “Add Selected”. In the popup window, just click “Invite” (no custom message necessary). Make sure “View Reports” is checked. Click “Save”.
- Prevent Multiple Votes and Anonymize Responses– In the top menu, go to “Survey” > "Survey options" > “Security”. Go to “In Survey: Prevent multiple submissions” and toggle to On. Also under “Security”, scroll to the bottom of the page to “Anonymize responses” and toggle to On.
- Distribute the Survey – Go to the Distributions tab and select “Emails” and “Send a message”. Choose who you want to invite by clicking “Create a new list” and add the email addresses of all voters. Click “Create” to save the email list, then select it and click “Next”. Fill out the email with text from the appropriate template below (leaving the survey links intact) and click “Next”. Send now.
Email Templates
Qualtrics Email Template for Incumbent Chair – Confidence Vote
It’s time for our annual chair selection. [Name] is currently serving in year [x] of their term as [department chair/school director], so we will be holding a confidence vote rather than a full election. Please use the link below to cast your vote. This Qualtrics survey is anonymous and eligible voters may only submit 1 response using this link. Voting closes on [insert date]. Thanks!
Email Template for Full Election – Nomination Period
We are beginning the process of selecting a new [department chair/school director]. Any eligible voting member may submit a nomination or self-nomination by sending their name to me by [insert date]. Nominees will be contacted to confirm their willingness to serve before being included on the ballot. Thanks!
Qualtrics Email Template for Full Election – Voting
Voting is now open for the [department chair/school director] election. The candidates are [Name 1, Name 2, etc.]. Please see the candidate statements below, and then use the link below to cast your vote. This Qualtrics survey is anonymous and eligible voters may only submit 1 response using this link. Voting closes on [insert date]. Thanks!
[Candidate #1 statement]
[Candidate #2 statement]