View Entire Evaluation Process

This document provides guidance on the [task name] step of a performance evaluation.

   

Step 1: Set Review Content (Manager)

 

Task Details

Assigned To: Manager

Workday Task List: Set Review Content: [Evaluation Type and Year] : [Employee Name]

Instructions For Step 1: Set Review Content

Instructions

Screenshot

  1. Once launched by HR, the manager will receive a task in Workday. Click on the My Tasks (inbox icon) to navigate to your task list. 

Screenshot of inbox icon in Workday

2. Select the Set Content: [Evaluation Name and Year] task for the employee you are working on. and click the Get Started button. 

Screenshot of Set Content task in Workday.

3. The employees job responsibilities will pull into the Job Responsibilities window from the content setting exercise that was completed in Summer/Fall 2025 after Workday launched. These responsibilities should match what is shown in the Standard Job Description (SJD).

Manager should:

    • add any unique responsibilities that are part of the employee's job as a new responsibility.
    • delete any responsibilities that do not apply to the employee's job.
    • enter expectations related to each specific responsibility in the corresponsing comment field. 

Managers should NOT:

    •  rewrite job responsibilities from what pulls from the SJD.

Once responsibilities have been finalized, click the NEXT button. 

Note: If the manager did not complete the set content exercise in summer/fall 2025, this window will be blank. The manager will need ot set the job expectations and goal setting during this step. 

Screenshot of Job Responsibilities window in Workday performance evaluation

4. In the Goals window, the manager will 

    • Update existing goals as needed.
    • Delete any goals that are no longer relevant. Do not delete completed goals.
    • Add new goals.

Each goal should be given a clear description and include a due date. Due dates should align with the end dates of future evaluation periods (July 1 for next Annual Evaluation, January 1 for next Midpoint evaluation

Goals should always be given a status of Not Started when they are added to the employee's evaluation for the first time. This is true even if the employee has started working on/exploring the goal so the evaluation history will clearly show when the goal was added. Updates to the status will be made during the next evaluation. 

Screenshot of Goals window in Workday performance evaluation

5. When all job responsibilities and goals are ready for the employee's review, click the Submit button. 

Note: While we are learning the new system, it is suggested that managers notify the employee that a task related to their evaluation should be in their Workday task inbox. This coordination helps the business process flow timely. 

Screenshot of the Submit button within an evaluation in Workday.

UP NEXT: Performance Evaluation | Complete Self Evaluation

Assigned To: Employee

 

Step 2: Complete Self Evaluation (Employee)

 

Task Details

Assigned To: Employee

Workday Task List: Self Evaluation: [Evaluation Type and Year]:[Employee Name]

Instructions For Step 2: Complete Self Evaluation

Instructions

Screenshot

  1. Navigate to the task inbox (inbox icon in upper right corner) and select the Complete Self Evaluation task. Click the Get Started button. 

Screenshot of Self Evaluation task in Workday

2. Review the job responsibilities closely, enter a performance rating, and add/update comments. Click the Next button. 

Do not make changes to the job responsibilities. If you disagree with something that is in the Responsibility field, add a detailed note to the comment field. 

Performance Ratings in Workday

Note: In Workday, employees must rate themselves on each of the responsibilities listed in their evaluation. This is different than the self-appraisal in the previous system. 

Screenshot of Evaluate Responsibilities window of Workday evaluation.

3. Carefully review the goals, update statuses, and add comments. Click the Next button. 

Goals should always be given a status of Not Started when they are added to the evaluation for the first time. This is true even if the employee has started working on/exploring the goal so the evaluation history will clearly show when the goal was added. Updates to the status will be made during the next evaluation. 

Screenshot of Review and Update Goals window in Workday evaluation.

4. Add supporting documents if needed (i.e. training certificates, kuddos, etc). Screenshot of Supporting Docs window in Workday evaluation.

5. When all job responsibilities and goals are ready for the manager's review, click the Submit button. 

Note: While we are learning the new system, it is suggested that employees notify the manager that a task related to the evaluation should be in their Workday task inbox. This coordination helps the business process flow timely. 

Screen shot of submit button in Workday evaluation.

UP NEXT: Performance Evaluation | Complete Manager Evaluation

Assigned To: Manager

 

Step 3: Complete Manager Evaluation (Manager)

 

Task Details

Assigned To: Manager

Workday Task List: Manager Evaluation: [Evaluation Name and Year] [Employee Name]

Instructions For Step 3: Complete Manager Evaluation

Instructions

Screenshot

  1. Navigate to the task inbox (inbox icon in upper right corner) and select the Manager Evaluation [Eval Name and Year] task for the employee you are working on. Click the Get Started button. 

Screenshot of Complete Manager Evaluation in Workday.

2. In the Evaluate Responsibilities window, enter performance ratings and comments for each responsibility listed. 

If the employee has expressed disagreement with any of the job responsibilities, the comments should reflect the differentiation in the comments field. 

The responsibilities that have pulled through from the Standard Job Description should not be rewritten. 

Click the Next button when all updates have been made. 

Performance Ratings in Workday

Screenshot of Evaluate Responsibilities window in Workday evaluation.

3. Review the goals and updates status and/or comments as needed. Click the Next button when all updates have been made.

Screenshot of Review Goals window in Workday evaluation.

4. Add supporting documents as needed (certificates, kuddos, etc) Screenshot of Supporting Documents window in Workday evaluation.

NOTE: This is the last chance to make a change to the evaluation content. NO changes can be made after clicking the Submit button. If changes are necessary, the entire evaluation up to this point must be deleted and started from the beginning of Step 1: Step 1: Set Review Content

5. Click the Submit button once you are sure that all evaluation content is correct. 

Note: While we are learning the new system, it is suggested that managers notify the employee that a task related to the evaluation should be in their Workday task inbox. This coordination helps the business process flow timely. 

Screenshot of Submit button in Workday Evaluation

UP NEXT: Performance Evaluation | To Do: Schedule Review Discussion

Assigned To: Employee

 

Step 4: Schedule Review Discussion (Manager)

 

Task Details

Assigned To: Manager

Workday Task List: Schedule Review Discussion: Manager Evaluation [Evaluation Type and Year]:[Employee Name]

Instructions For Step 4: Schedule Review Discussion

Instructions

Screenshot

Note: This is simply a reminder. Scheduling the meeting to discuss the evaluation occurs outside of Workday. It is best practice for managers to complete the steps below after the evaluation meeting has been scheduled and the employee has accepted the invitation. 

  1. Navigate to the task inbox (inbox icon in upper right corner) and select the Schedule Review Discussion: Manager Evaluation [Eval Name and Year] To Do reminder for the employee you are working on.

Screenshot of Schedule Review Discussion task in Workday.

2. Click the Submit button. 

Screenshot of submit button in Workday evaluation

UP NEXT: Performance Evaluation | Employee Acknowledgement

Assigned To: Employee

 

Step 5: Employee Acknowledgement (Employee)

 

Task Details

Assigned To: Employee

Workday Task List: Performance Evaluation Employee Acknowledgement: [Employee Name]

Instructions For Step 5: Employee Acknowledgement

Instructions

Screenshot

  1. Navigate to the task inbox (inbox icon in upper right corner) and select the Performance Evaluation Employee Acknowledgement task. Click the Get Started button. 

Screenshot of Employee Acknowledgment task in Workday evaluation.

2. Review the information on Job Responsibilities window and click the Next button at the bottom.  Screenshot of Next button.
3. Click the radio button to acknowledge the performance evaluation. Screenshot of employee acknowledgement radio button in Workday evaluation.

4. Click the Submit button.

Note: While we are learning the new system, it is suggested that employees notify the manager that a task related to the evaluation should be in their Workday task inbox. This coordination helps the business process flow timely. 

Screenshot of submit button in Workday evaluation

UP NEXT: Performance Evaluation | Manager Acknowledgement and Finalization

Assigned To: Manager

 

Step 6: Manager Acknowledgement and Finalization (Manager)

 

Task Details

Assigned To: Manager

Workday Task List: Performance Evaluation Manager Acknowledgement: [Employee Name]

Instructions For Step 6: Manager Acknowledgement and Finalization

Instructions

Screenshot

  1. Navigate to the task inbox (inbox icon in upper right corner) and select the Performance Evaluation Manager Acknowledgement task for the employee you are working on. Click the Get Started button. 

Screen shot of manager acknowledgement task in Workday evaluation.

2. Scroll to the bottom of the Summary window and click the Next button.  screen shot of next button in Workday evaluation.

3. Click the acknowledgement radio button. 

4. Click the Submit button. 

Clicking the submit button should trigger a pop-up that indicates the evaluation has been successfully completed.

Screen shot of acknowledgement and submit buttons in Workday evaluation.

 

 

Resources

Performance Reviews Overview

Performance Ratings in Workday

Evaluations in Workday are a multi-step business process that flows back and forth between the manager and employee. Lack of a task in your Workday Task Inbox is not an indicator that the evaluation is complete. It could simply mean that the business process is sitting in the other individuals task inbox. To determine the status of an evaluation, refer to the performance window of the employee's profile.



Keywords:
performance management, evaluation, eval, probation, annual, mid-point, midpoint, summary 
Doc ID:
157565
Owned by:
Sarah J. in SMPH Human Resources
Created:
2025-12-18
Updated:
2025-12-18
Sites:
SMPH Human Resources